Insurance Lead Vendor Profiles
What each vendor sells, how they define exclusivity, what they require as a minimum — and whether they will show you a price without a phone call.
How this market actually splits
Insurance lead vendors divide on one line before price: whether they publish terms at all. Of the vendors profiled here, two publish prices and three quote on request. Exclusivity is the second line, and it is defined differently by nearly every vendor that uses the word.
The vendors, side by side
| Vendor | Sells | Verticals | Exclusivity | Publishes pricing? | Minimum order | Returns / credits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Datalot (now Centerfield Insurance Services) | Web leads, inbound calls, live transfers | Auto, home, life, health, Medicare, commercial | Not published | No | Not published | Not yet checked |
| Aged Lead Store | Aged internet leads, 3–365 days old (IUL 181–500) | Auto, life, IUL, health, final expense, mortgage, home, home improvement, solar | Shared | Yes | $100 per order | Up to 20% replaced: wrong or disconnected numbers, or your existing clients |
| Lead Heroes | Telemarketed leads, live transfers, pre-set appointments, custom calling campaigns | Final expense, Medicare Supplement, T65, term life | 100% exclusive — stated as not shared or resold | Yes | 20 leads | Transfers replaced if the caller did not ask to be transferred; none stated for leads |
| Benepath | Data leads, phone calls, clicks platform | Individual & family health, group health, Medicare, commercial, life, home, auto | Exclusive | No | Not published | Not yet checked |
| Hometown Quotes | Internet leads for agents | Auto, home, life, health | Sold 4 or fewer times; exclusive options offered | No | Not published | Credit for six stated reasons, incl. invalid phone and email, and duplicates within 30 days |
Disclosure:InsureLeads publishes these profiles and also sells insurance leads, so it competes with every vendor listed. The profiles record dated facts from each vendor’s own site and carry no ratings.
Every value was read from that vendor’s own public site on the date shown on its profile page. “Not published” means the vendor does not state it publicly — that absence is a finding, not an omission on our part. “Not yet checked” marks a vendor whose return terms we have not read yet. No third-party review scores appear here by policy: they cannot be reliably re-verified. Last reviewed 2026-11-04.
Two marketplaces without a profile here are compared on the same questions — published pricing, exclusivity and contract terms — in our side-by-side of SmartFinancial and QuoteWizard leads. For the prices that 9 of 18 vendors we read do publish, by line and format with a source link on every figure, see the insurance lead price index.
What to ask any vendor before ordering
Most of this market will not publish terms, so the evaluation happens on a call. Get these seven answers in writing before money moves, and check the cost per lead by line and format before you take the first quote.
- What is the per-unit price at the volume I would actually buy?
- What is the minimum order, and is it a lead count or a dollar floor?
- Is the record sold once ever, or once per vertical?
- Is there a contract term, or can I stop after one batch?
- What is the credit policy for a disconnected number or wrong-party contact?
- What consent evidence comes with the record, and who is named in it?
- What happens to the record after my exclusivity window closes?
Our own answers are published rather than quoted: the rate card on pricing, the ordering model on how it works, credit terms on the lead replacement policy, and sourcing on how we source leads. There is no long-term contract on any lead product, and aged leads carry no minimum spend. If the answers you collect make buying look like the wrong fit, insurance lead generation for agents sets buying against generating your own leads: what each costs, how long it takes and the consent rules for both.
Frequently asked questions
What is a lead vendor?
A lead vendor is a company that sells agents the contact details, or a live call, of a consumer who has shown interest in insurance. Vendors differ in how the record is made and how often it is sold: real-time generators sell web form fills, calls and transfers as they happen; telemarketers create the lead on an outbound call; aged resellers sell records weeks or months old that may have been bought before; and marketplaces route one shopper to several buyers. The "Sells" and "Exclusivity" columns show which model each vendor here uses.
Which insurance lead vendors publish their prices?
Few. Of the five profiled here, Aged Lead Store publishes a per-lead price grid by lead age and order size, and Lead Heroes lists prices on its order forms rather than its product pages. Datalot (now Centerfield), Benepath and Hometown Quotes quote on request. That is why the comparison table asks "publishes pricing?" rather than listing a price.
Why do so few lead companies publish pricing?
A quoted price can be set per buyer, which is worth more to the seller than a public rate is. The practical effect for an agent is that two vendors cannot be compared without two sales calls, and the number you are given reflects what the salesperson thinks you will pay.
What is the single most important question to ask a lead vendor?
How exclusivity is defined. Vendors use the same word for very different products: sold once ever, sold once per vertical, or exclusive for a window and then resold as aged. The answer changes the value of the record more than the price does.
Are these profiles reviews?
No. They record structural facts read from each vendor’s own site on a stated date — what they sell, which verticals, exclusivity, minimum order and whether a price is published. They deliberately carry no star ratings, because third-party review scores cannot be reliably re-verified.